NDP MLA skewers B.C. Liberals on lack of support for gay-straight alliances

    1 of 2 2 of 2

      NDP MLA Spencer Chandra Herbert has long been an advocate of antihomophobia measures and gay-straight alliances in schools.

      Today (May 14) during the question period in the B.C. Legislature, Chandra Herbert sought answers for why the B.C. government has not followed the examples of other provinces such as Alberta which have passed legislation to ensure GSAs are in schools.

      Minister of Education Peter Fassbender responded by explaining that the ERASE Bullying strategy ensures that bullying is prevented in schools. However, Chandra Herbert pressed on as to why specific action has not been taken for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender students.

      UBC researchers have found a reduction in suicide, overall discrimination, and substance abuse in schools which have GSAs and antihomophobia measures. Activists have pointed out that anithomophobia and GSAs address issues that go beyond bullying, such as the exclusion, omission, and invisibility of LGBT people.

      Here is a Hansard transcript of the exchange between Chandra Herbert and Fassbender:

      S. Chandra Herbert: We all know gay-straight alliances save lives. In Alberta their government has declared that students in any school that ask for one will get one. They will make sure it happens.

      Ontario has said the same. Saskatchewan has said that if there's a school that won't provide one, they'll look to cut their funding. Yet here in B.C., this Liberal government refuses. They say they will not lift one finger to ensure that kids get that students in any school that ask for one will get one. 

      My question to the Premier: why?

      Hon. P. Fassbender: I thank the member for the question.

      British Columbia has led the country. The Premier has been recognized for leading the country by other first ministers across this country for our ERASE Bullying strategy—investment in ensuring that schools and communities have the tools they need to ensure that no student, no person, is bullied for any reason.

      It has been successful. We've seen great work being done in schools. We stand on the record that says very clearly that no person in this province should be discriminated against or bullied for any reason.

      Madame Speaker: The member for Vancouver–West End on a supplemental.

      S. Chandra Herbert: This government stands on a record of failing, absolutely failing lesbian, gay, bi and trans students. The minister knows it. All of this side knows it. You're failing them. Gay-straight alliances cut suicide risk in half. Yet this government…. When these students ask for help in their most vulnerable times, the Premier, the minister, refuse to do anything. They will not ensure that kids get these clubs that are life-savers, that make sure they're not at such high risks of suicide. It's shameful.

      Alberta acted. They're a Conservative government. Ontario acted. They're a Liberal government. New Democrats are calling for action in Saskatchewan. Their Conservative-affiliated government is looking to cut the funding. Yet here in B.C., which is, I suppose, a leader in failing our students, this government says nothing, does nothing, turns their back on these students crying out for help.

      How can the minister stand and claim to be a leader when he so clearly knows that his government is a failure?

      Hon. P. Fassbender: The heart of the ERASE strategy is very clear, and that is that we support the diversity of all students in the province of British Columbia.

      Interjections.

      Madame Speaker: Members, Members.

      Interjection.

      Madame Speaker: Powell River–Sunshine Coast.

      Hon. P. Fassbender: We support the boards of education across this province, independent schools that have implemented LGBTQ clubs as part of their local initiatives in the schools, with the students at the heart of it, who know who their friends are and work with them to ensure that they are not bullied or discriminated against.

      In addition, because we have safe school coordinators in every single district in this province, they're not only working with the students, they're working with community so that the school communities are safe and inclusive communities.

      You can follow Craig Takeuchi on Twitter at twitter.com/cinecraig. You can also follow the Straight's LGBT coverage on Twitter at twitter.com/StraightLGBT.

      Comments

      4 Comments

      Murray Corren

      May 14, 2015 at 4:30pm

      It's the same response I have been hearing for years that "all students need to be respected, all students need to be safe". And that's just fine. However, it completely avoids the issue that queer students need a place (gay straight alliances) at school where their specific needs and concerns can be addressed and where they and their allies can come together in mutual support. The "one size fits all" approach ,which the ERASE program is, fails to do that. This government needs to mandate that ALL schools receiving public funding must permit the establishing of GSAs when students ask for them. Nothing less will do.

      Jodi Derkson

      May 14, 2015 at 7:13pm

      While I respect the Erase Bullying Program, I've attended a workshop and the initiative does not support students within each school. It is up to the administration to adopt EB's strategies and ideas and so it's not always done. A gay/straight alliance within each school would be a ready to use, safe place for all students to visit and is something Erase Bullying simply cannot offer. It seems that Mr. Fassbender hasn't been in schools lately to witness EB and its reach because frankly, there isn't one - at least not one that will truly support those in most need (the ones who won't call a help line but will actually just end their struggle). Things need to change. @imperativeEd #voicesintoaction

      Morgane Oger - Trans Alliance Society

      May 15, 2015 at 4:09pm

      ERASE seems to be blandly vague to the point of pointlessness.

      The ERASE program website features a handy search function to help people look for context-specific help.

      Sadly, when the word "transgender" is entered, there are no results. That word never appears, NOT ONCE, in a web site about bullying. In fairness, the term gender identity DOES appear once.

      When the words gay, lesbian, or bisexual are entered, there seem to be only external links to services that are unrelated to the ministry of education. When I asked for help through the contact webform regarding a bullying problem I was dealing with (as the chair of the trans alliance society), I received the following response more than 3 weeks (!!) later:

      "Thank you for your email where you mentioned your children are being bullied and you are concerned about the lack of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Transsexual, Queer, Questioning and 2-Spirited (LGBTQ2) supports and resources that are available for students and their families on our website.

      If you are able to provide me with the name of your School District where these bullying incidents are occurring, I can connect you with the Safe School Coordinator to assist you and your children. We are also working to improve our ERASE Bullying website so that more LGBTQ2 supports and resources are available. In the meantime, I would like to suggest two resources that might be of interest to you: the Out in Schools (http://outinschools.com/) and the Trans Alliance Society (www.transalliancesociety.org). Also, I encourage you to visit the Healthy Schools BC Website (http://www.healthyschoolsbc.ca) and use the search function to find available programs and supports for students with parents who identify as LGBTQ2.

      Government takes the issue of student safety seriously. The Ministry of Education has established the ERASE bullying strategy to help ensure all students feel safe, accepted and respected. A key component of the ERASE bullying strategy is an extensive training program for educators and community partners to help them proactively foster safe school cultures, prevent and address bullying and undertake violence threat risk assessment. As part of the ERASE training, there is a specific focus to identify and address harassment based on sexual orientation, race, gender and other aspects of discrimination outlined in the human rights code."

      Advocate

      May 16, 2015 at 4:10pm

      When will this MLA start representing people other than gay people?