Commentary | HST

Bill Vander Zalm: Why I am speaking out against Gordon Campbell's HST

By Bill Vander Zalm

There is an unwritten rule that former premiers don’t speak out against sitting premiers regarding policy decisions. The reason for this is that being the leader of the government is a distinct and rare privilege. Once you’ve been there, you’ve had your chance to implement the changes you wanted to see, and the people who follow you are entitled to do the same.

But the problem here is that we have a premier who is operating more and more by stealth. The consequences of his actions are extremely damaging to our province, and in many cases, can never be reversed. The HST is just the latest betrayal—but for most British Columbians, it is the straw that broke the camel’s back.

See also

Guy Dauncey: HST should have been an ecologically harmonized sales tax

Jane Sterk: HST won't help B.C. adapt to climate change

Gabriel Yiu: The B.C. Liberal government's HST can be stopped

Chris Delaney: Gordon Campbell's HST is a costly betrayal

Carole James: We can stop the B.C. Liberals' HST tax grab

Harmonized sales tax will raise ticket prices

Harmonized sales tax hurts alternative health

Ex–Liberal MLA John Nuraney wants harmonized sales tax "neutrality" details

Sustainable-building advocates worry HST will undermine energy efficiency

It is one thing for a party or a candidate to promise something, and then, after being elected to government, find that the promise was unrealistic, or that new information makes implementing it impossible. In such cases, even though the public is rightly disappointed and angered, they will often forgive such a “broken promise”. It is quite another thing to promise “not” to do something, and then to turn around and do exactly the opposite.

Such a maneuver is incompetent at best, downright deceitful at worst. Take B.C. Rail for example. Gordon Campbell, having lost the 1996 election after revealing plans to sell the people’s railway, promised on a stack of Bibles never to sell it, or to even contemplate selling it. The ink had barely dried on the new premier’s letterhead when he arranged for a 999-year lease of the railway and the right of way. That is not a broken promise—that is a total fraud.

Then came B.C. Hydro. We were told Hydro was sacred. Then, we were told that in order to make it more efficient and cost effective, it had to be run by a big multinational in Bermuda. But hydro rates went up, not down.

The list goes on and on. B.C. Ferries had to be made in Germany instead of locally. The Sea to Sky had to be widened before Highway 1. The Port Mann Bridge must be tolled. The Liberals will fix health care and end surgery wait lists, but now we see wait times will lengthen under massive cuts to the number of surgical procedures that will coincide with the implementation of the HST. It’s all just ploy to pay for big Olympic projects that are out of control.

Where does it all end? With a raid by the RCMP on the legislature, where now we see the possibility that e-mail evidence related to the criminal trial has been ordered destroyed—by someone. Who the premier won’t tell us, nor is he asking who himself.

Premier Campbell spent a ton of money during the boom times of the world economy on big projects—some would say wasteful. Now, when times are tough, he is clawing it all back with cuts to services and a new HST tax grab to pay for it all. He’s got it backwards—so backwards that British Columbians will face big cuts, higher taxes, and no infrastructure projects sorely needed during a tough time. The cupboard is bare because all the food was eaten during good times.

I say Gordon Campbell knew all along that he was going to bring in this tax. Just like he knew he would sell B.C. Rail, carve up Hydro, and cut health-care services instead of fix health care.

If the media or the Opposition had been doing their job, I might not have needed to speak out. But to stand by and watch it all happen without trying to save the province I and so many others love and cherish would be a worse mistake.

We have organized a non-partisan rally for noon on September 19, in front of the Vancouver Art Gallery. This rally will be the kickoff for a people’s initiative against the HST. The initiative will require 10 percent of the registered voters in each constituency to sign on within a 90-day period, and could force the government to hold a referendum on the question of whether we want the HST.

We can’t let this happen. Join me in saying no to the HST. Together, we can save B.C.

Bill Vander Zalm was the premier of British Columbia from 1986 to 1991 and is the author of Bill Vander Zalm: For the People.

Comments

Sarah McSevney
How do I go about signing the petition?
 
Garry from Surrey
is there any web site for Mr.Vander Zalm or for the September 19 rally i can go to?
 
Stephen Hui
@Sarah McSevney:

The NDP's petition is at http://www.bcndp.ca/hstpetition

The BC Restaurant & Foodservices Association has another one at http://www.bcrfa.com/home/hst-petition

You can find more in this Facebook group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=105998706732

@Garry from Surrey:

There's a Facebook event for the rally: http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=114652512862

There's also http://saynotohstinbc.ca/


 
thankful!
Zalm you are the man. BC needs a patriot like you right now. Thank you!
 
Gordon no relation
About time someone told it like it was!
 
bobby
well I'd never in my life thought I'd say this but GO ZALM !! his article is astounding to say the least ,Ijust never thoughthe had it in him,,it's to bad a couple of minor indicretions and the fact he was surrounded by dimwits of campbells ilk interfered in his premiership,,after reading his article here ,I'm thinkin' he maybe could have done alright and having been forced to say that out of conscience it doesn't hurt so bad after all.
 
No Effective Opposition
Vander Zalm was a terrible premier who is now looking good in retrospect. He's exactly right about there being no effective opposition party at a time when we need but are sadly lacking strong voices to hold the Liberals feet to the fire. As long as the NDP continues to pick leaders like Carole James, the Liberals will be the permanent ruling party.
 
Canada's Twin#1
Way to go Bill you just touched the tip of Gordon Campbell's sh....pile. It gets worse. I'll address abit. E-mail scandel was not just BC. Rail
Gordon said, I"m aware of the situation in the Comox Valley I'll handle it. That's when the government e-mails and electronic records started to be wiped out. Have the evidence right out of a governments workers mouth. Next as the sh..pile stench is so toxic it brings you to the next one Gordos' drug development and the people being killed far to many in the Comox Valley. I had to go to the FDA for that one and the White House. Maybe you like to do a second rally in the Comox Valley because too many love this province and Campbell with so many UN violations just may find the next violation a matter of international prosecution.

Canada'sTwin#1
 
RS
"Once you’ve been there, you’ve had your chance to implement the changes you wanted to see."

And therein lies the problem. Shouldn't it be to implement the changes the people want to see.
 
Rightwing Zalm
Isn't Van Der Zalm a ultra-rightwing conservative who drove BC into the ground? He then paved the way for his socialist friends in the NDP to take over BC for 10 years and drive it further into the ground.

Rightwing nationalists never cease to love leftwing socialists.
 
Comox
So are you spewing crazy or can you give any more details?
 
beelzebub
Another envelope taking, self aggrandizing, talking head expert speaks. Whatever the views on the Premier, he actually was elected and will be here for a few more years. You reap what you sow. A direct reflection of the voter apathy.
 
big sister
Bill--you should be commended for your courrage .
As a senior in BC I support your cause, I want to give you my signature .

As a senior who built this province and has been direspected by this goverment , Bill--would you like to support my cause since you love this province as I do and do your next rally in theComox Valley .

We all know that the HST is going to be a blow on the senior population of this province .
It will be more determiental to the seniors when Gordon Campbell 's hidden scandels is added on top of it .
It will be devistating to seniors population throughout this province .
Sincerly ,
senior [ metis ] in the Comox Valley

PS -- Comox you have a question and you' ve made a satement.
If you want more details ask your federal MP he has them all .
As for your first question that would be in Mr. Vander Zam 's in seeing the evidence and why he made a statement on the HST.
The only thing that is spewing in the Comox Valley is the toxic substances mix in with bodly fluids spewing out of the body with all the sudden death , short battle with cancer and every other clinical trials that the hospital is running without people's knowledge .
With Bill seeing the evidence he'll be able to determine who is crazy .
Your questionable statement you put in has been addressed by the FDA in USA and their appropriate responce was forworded to Mr Harper .

Again you might like to consult your local federal MP , I'm sure he can obtain the rest of the detail you request from Mr Harper .
 
Comox
big sister, Canada's Twin#1

What the hell are you talking about? It sounds terrifying. If we wait for the media to pick it up it could take a while, if it ends up in the courts it could be stalled indefinitely!

I have not heard a peep about anything controversial in Comox except for the racist attack??!!

Go public with it already!
 
grande soeur
MISERICORDE

Yes talking about hell Comox .Yes I heard it's terrifying .

I have lots of time and the media likes a good long story since they prviously wrote about it when international inspectors came in .

It stayed in the news over six months and why many steped down from their jobs .

As the meaning of your statements you only have to know Ryan's story when the American's were horrified what the Canadians had done .

Comox Valley is worse all the way down to Victoria and why G Campbell 's shit pill is so toxic .

Like Mr. Abbott -----hell my papers are in order to .
 
Rocky23
Bill I hope you will come to the Comox Valley as you can have my signature too. As a youth Mr. Campbell should have been honest to the youth voters about his tax. That's why some don't vote because the youth don't like the example the older generation set for the younger generation..
Big Sister as a youth I'm aware of the toxic sh... pi.... too in the Comox Valley and I am disgusted in what lenghths the goverment mps local, provincial and federal and the Preimer and the Prime Minister have done to cover the issues up. Mr.Campbell should learn from the youth you can never cover up a lie because there will aways be a toxic smell. A local federal mp was in our local papers rallying for the Prime Ministers cause and was pictured with a new shovel. I wonder if he could send one to Mr. Campbell and the other one to the Prime Minister so they can begin to clean up their messes before the next election and possible provincial re-call since the youth voters are non to happy.Big sister when a youth loses their mother father- grandma -grandpa -brother -sister -aunt -uncle they understand hell when it was someones wrongfull actions that caused it all for the sake of a buck. Yes FDA inspection needs to come in and as a youth I'm willing to call them. Previoulsy I called Hillary Clintons campaign office and told them all about the wrong in this town.
 
Surrey Hellboy
Surrey is going to be overcrowded with more people who cannot get rehab in other communities, rehab run by Ministry of Mental Health and Addictions, which was forced to convert Mental Health clinics into Methadone clinics because the province pays for that, but pretends mental health is all preventative.

It is when optimal nutritional needs are met, but federal nutritional guidelines are about averages, not about optimizing human nutrition.

Until optimizing our nutritional needs along with our intellectual needs, and everything else, becomes advocation from cradle to grave, mental health and addictions issues will continue to grow.

Why this is pertinent to the anti-HST movement is simple: HST will also add costs to our nutritional needs too. This means more cheap imports of nutritionally deficient fruits and vegetables, as well as junkfood.

Fast-food obesity will continue to rise until people decide on breakfast burritoes or chicken wraps & orange juice over McBurgers & Fries, and Diet Coke.
 
What the...?
Canada's Twin #1 and grande soeur,

What the heck are you two going on about? If whatever it is you two are ranting about is pertinent or relevant in some way, why all the pretense?
 
Comox
Mercy League Canada-La ligue Canadienne de la Misericorde Inc. Comox, B.C. ?

another clue please?
 
Strong Oppostion
Carol's oppostion has been none stop against Campbell yet voters failed as voters give the Liberals a majority vote despite knowing Campbell can't be trusted. CPRail, etc, etc, etc but yet BC residents failed to vote in itself in a healthy oppostion. Thats right if you don't trust a government in what it has to say don't give it all the say and then ask what happened to the oppostion. You can not have a healthy oppostion without media on board and a majority vote just ask Harper.
 
sleepswithangels
Whatever the mysterious "shit pile" in the Comox Valley is, it seems to have caused some serious brain damage.

As for the straight shooting Zalm, is there a new political entity in the works Bill?
Seems to me there are a lot of angry voters who who will flee the Libs and won't vote NDP or Green. They need a new home....and a charismatic leader.
SMBs
 
Canada's Twin#1
The shit pile in Comox is well known in the political circle. As for the medical condition people fighting for their lives with full blown cancer, sorry it doesn't effect their heads. Since your so conservative and liberal with your words. Pipeline- #2- Give them the drug till they can no longer stand the toxitity follow till death. BC drug trials. The person with brain damage is the one administering the drug to people without there knowledege and the politican who maniplated the tri-policy statement to do it. Even sicker is the Prime Minister who says on American TV Canada does some drug regulation while he shows a blatant indifferance to those who have died as result. Angry voters don't intend to flee anything. Then intend hold all government where needed to account. As once said Gordon Campbell will never be remebered for what he did rather those who have been harmed and every other politican attached to the shit pile. As for the Prime Minister wisdom says he's gone in the next election.
Bill as the senior said it takes courage for what your doing and it is appreciated that some politicans can make a right choice in there heart for the people of this province who have suffered far too much by the current governing party. As for the ones who have done and are doing nothing sorry coward is the word that is being used democratically.

Canada's Twin#1
 
Funny HST Video
Thanks to who ever made this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atiLnxSKmec
 
JoeBC

Bill, I used to think that you understood some finance and Economics, but now it is very very clear that you have NOT taken professional advice on the matter of HST.
Bill, PLEASE TAKE SOME PROFESSIONAL EXPERT ADVICE to help you understand the workings and effects of HST/"Value Added Tax" as compared to harmful PST/"Sales and Use Tax"
The existing PST is EXTREMELY HARMFUL TO BC and should have been replaced many many many years ago.

Unfotunately politicians at both extremes of the political spectrum have lacked the courage to get rid of the PST through the 80s,90s and finally now at the end of the 2000's we are finally going to have the problem solved so we can have future prosperity.

I have the same advice for all readers: "Seek paid Professional independent Expert advice".

GOODBYE AND GOOD RIDDANCE PST!
We will not miss you.
 
dude9
Their not getting rid of the pst their merging it with another and applying it to more products and services which he have a huge impact on this province. Do your math
 
JoeBC
As I said before, dude9,
"I have the same advice for all readers: "Seek paid Professional independent Expert advice"."




 
NO HST FOR ME
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QseiGxp1p8&feature=player_embedded

FUnny HST Video - on youtube top comedy video today Bloody HST
 
LOL/LOL/LOL
You abused your "rare privilege" which ended in chaos and corruption. You have ZERO comprehension of the term "rules".

Don't be sucked in by this disgraced, former Premier people. This guy wouldn't know the truth if he choked on it.

Me thinks he sees himself in Campbell's corruption. It takes one to know one.
 
john b
While I do agree that there could be some good with the hst, I am very angry that Gordo has lied once again and i for one would be happy to see him in jail. Probably wont happen but I'm still waiting for Brian Mulroney to get thrown in jail as well.
When are the self involved youth of bc finally going to stand up and do its civic responsibility ?
A Plague on your house mr campbell.
Shame on you bc youth
 
B.F.
This is my first post in the politics section. Why I am so against the H.S.T. you ask?

- it hurts the small to medium income families (like mine)
- it's another 7% that I don't have to spare
- once here, it will be here to stay (no going back)
- I'm worried that I won't have enough to make ends meet, as it's difficult enough as is.

I'm hoping everyone who's affected by the H.S.T. to join me and thousands of others who's signed the petition at stophst .ca
 
Low income are already going hungry
This tax is going to take the poorest in the land and leave them with no way to fend for themselves in the big city with nothing to eat. Campbell's fixation with the pockets of the poor have been his obbession since getting in office as Campbell tries to rid BC of its social programs in good times as well as bad.
You don't think Mr. Campbell is taking the opportunity to rid BC of it social network for good? Because it sure looks that way while eliminating proverty by killing off the poor.
 
scamper
First: Our wealthy "premier" (Who doesn't have to live on $1,600 per month U.I.C. which barely covers my mortgage payment, not food for my three growing children) says we're all going to benefit from this tax, but I have worked for too many large corporations and found that they will take advantage of every tax break that comes their way and very, very seldom return it to the general population. They are answerable to the shareholders, not you and me. Profit is profit no matter where it comes from.

Second: If I needed two accountants to keep track of a two tax system, why would I keep two, if now I only needed one. I feel that there will be job losses in the future.

Three: The government we have is pro-big business, because they need the dollar big business provides for their political agenda. Need I say more...and.

Four: What ever happened to government accountability. Isn't the government supposed to answer to you and me...the people, yet why is it so difficult to simply fire the man if he is not providing for the needs of the population in general. In the private sector we'd be let go, fired, or simply told there is insufficient work to keep me employed.

Nuff said...
 
Eryn
Didn't vote this time as I was too disgusted by the Liberals lies and HUGE wage increases. Would never vote for NDP....no one to vote for. My impression is what a bunch of liars!!! AND the unelected Translink board that is a greater danger of taxing us to death!!!
 
Fed Up
If anyone actually wishes to DO SOMETHING and work towards ridding ourselves of the HST, and maybe Gordon Campbell as a side benefit, call the NDP office and ask how to get on board collecting signatures with Mr. VanderZalm et al. This can happen if people get off their lazy, don't care to vote type asses!
 
AAG
Please tell me how I can HELP with this. I'll get OTHERS to help me cover this area of BC - we have GOT to stop this tax!
 
Bea S.
I am a retired senoir, I have a small poultry business, which helps to supplement my income, the HST, will wipe out my business, as many of the smll poultry growers can ill afford more costs added to their bill, thus they will shut down. Therefore it will cost them more to live because they will have to purchase from the inflated prices in the grocery stores.
We need to stop this madman in his tracks or chair, whichever comes first.
 
russ p.
I can remeber when the social credit was in power, the province was prospering and feel the government was more intune with the people. lets revive the social credit party in BC and maybe Bill would again take the job of premier. couldnt be worse than what we have now.
 
korr
I don;t know alot of things but I know this; as a small business owner in B.C. I am sinking with no life raft in sight. Taxes are bad for the population, bad for the economy, and bad for business in general. We are in bad times right now and the last thing we need is more bad news. The HST will inevitally put many of us small business owners under, you know the small businesses that Mr. Campbell promised to help! I am not an NDP supporter nor a liberal or green party supporter, I am against lies, corruption, and stupid government decisions... this latest one (HST) is just another in a long line of stupid tax grabbing decisions made by all our governments but it is one that I will go down fighting before it puts me under. Tell me were to sign Mr. Vander Zalm.
 
Vernon
I come from a family of small, local business owners. As a individual who works for my income from a local plumbing company, I see how the hst is going to hurt my pocket, in the obvious ways. On the other side, which is where I stand, this is going to put more money into my familys, and company's pocket, which I think is great. Small business owners are generally hard working, deserving people, unlike the majority of todays lazy, something for nothing youth.
I myself can see myself being self employed in the future, and am attracted to the thought of ease of accounting, and other benefits that adhere to the Hst.

Par example, I know someone who runs a company locally, and is involved in landscaping. A large part of his work involves gravel. He picks it up from the supplier, pays his two taxes, and can only charge one. Hense money out of his pocket. A 100$ load turns into a 107 $load. Im glad he will be getting his money back.

And this is why I have to support the hst, Thank you.
 
Anne
Has anyone heard of the new tax where they tax the person who is selling the car, not just the person buying the car.
Is this for real or is it a joke?
 
Wallaby2
To Joe BC: There's a gap the size of the Grand Canyon between getting rid of the PST and imposing the HST. Contrary to the Chamber of Commerce spiel, small business does NOT support the HST...just check with the CofC survey results in Saanich, New Westminster and NV. And if anyone thinks the big corporations will pass on their savings to consumers? Maybe in Florida, California and offshore...not around BC.
 
Dean Lewis

Thank you Mr.Vander Zalm for what you are doing.
Thank you, thank you, thank you .
Much appreciated.
 
Conspiracy Theorist
Any government that would even propose such an absurd tax at a time of general public economic hardship and increasing costs, is also capable of doing it as a diversion from attention from something worse.
The Rich Coleman land give-away at Jordan River shows just how low the Campbell government will go in betraying the public trust.
How about an enquiry into what else is going on under the table potentially lining the pockets of corporate interests/friends of Gordie ?
 
geffen
The English language seems to as much at a loss in BC as taxes - Is the name JoeBC the correct spelling .... or was what we all read really written by JokeBC??
 
Sue Innes
Behind you all the way!!!! Thanks so much for speaking out. I am in Parksville....where can I go to sign up?
 
Anonymous BC Coward
What is the web site for Bill Vander Zalm's petition? I want to sign it and get all my friends to sign it. Everyone I know hates the HST, and Gordon Campbell doesn't seem to care what tax payers think/want/need.
 
the Dood
Zalm, you have never really touched on the HST itself! All you did was touch on all the past things that have gone wrong..not sure how this conveys a message about HST and how bad it is. Why not take a look at some of the benefits...that if followed....will benefit all of BC. Issues such as this do not pass along benefits the next day. Please, have vision.
 
neaj@shaw.ca
thank you for being thier for B.C..please send me your petition so I can sign it, and I have many more who woukd like to sign also.
 
smarty pants
JoeBC doesn't know what he is talking about.
Bring on the petition so I can sign it. As for Campbell and Hansen..dig a hole and jump into it....we won't miss you.
 
Edward Simpkins
I have an idea to accelerate the progress of the petition.The explanation is a bit involved, and it may sound pedantic, so please indulge me. Scotland, that great country, is a favored location for rock climbers from all over Europe, and at Glencoe where I climbed as a lad, there is an hotel: 'The Clachaig Inn'. To this day, there is a sign on the door: it reads, NO HAWKERS OR CAMPBELLS. Now, this acrimony is not new; it goes back to the massacre of Glencoe in 1692, when 38 members of the McDonald clan, women and children included, were murdered by government troops led by Captain Robert Campbell. In the eyes of the Scots, centuries have done little to erase the ignominy of this act. Campbell and his men had earlier enjoyed the legendary Highland hospitality of the McDonalds before he treacherously turned on his hosts and ordered his men to murder every last one of them, including his own niece and her husband. Three hundred years later children all over Scotland are taught " never trust a Campbell" It seems that this malevolent 'treachery gene' has survived the centuries to reappear in BC's Premier, Gordon Campbell What better place to further the ends of this petition, then, that at 'McDonald's all across BC? I'm sure the franchise would be happy to promote it. Apart from old scores, think of the free publicity.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.